SQM like luci

[some_dsl_problems]

Hello,

I have just upgraded my dsl modem to Keenetic Extra DSL last week. I am very happy with the interface. Very nice and clean design. But my main goal to buy this device was only sqm/openwrt. Since it is advertised to support openwrt packages I touht that I can install or as in front of the box it says QOS so I made up my mind and bought it. When I open the interface and enable QoS it said QoS is not queuing only work on torrent traffic. Which lowered my expectations and I have opened the dslreport speed test but there were no change on my buffer bloat score (D). So I installed the entware but it also doesnt support sqm-scripts because it is a user mode addon. So I know sqm takes too much cpu but I dont need speed I need stable connection and no buffer bloat. My network is only 32mbit so extra dsl's cpu should and could easily handle that. SQM should be an industry standart on keenetic modems. Its the only thing I care when I buy one. Please add luci-app-sqm to keenetic.

Best pings,

[sergeyk]

6 минут назад, some_dsl_problems сказал:

Which lowered my expectations and I have opened the dslreport speed test but there were no change on my buffer bloat score (D).

What a firmware version do you use? Please try 3.6 Beta 1 from the "Preview" update channel.

[some_dsl_problems]

3 minutes ago, sergeyk said:

What a firmware version do you use? Please try 3.6 Beta 1 from the "Preview" update channel.

currently I am on work, I will get back home and try 6-7 hours later & give feedback. Thank you.

[Le ecureuil]

19 минут назад, some_dsl_problems сказал:

SQM should be an industry standart on keenetic modems. 

It is already there, try 3.6.

[some_dsl_problems]

Hello again, Im back home.

Before upgrading I made a test with 3.4.12 Qos enabled :

after upgrade 3.6 beta2 without Qos installed:

Upload did improve but no change on download.

 

After installing and enabling with auto bandwith mesurement Qos almost the same results like without Qos:

(upload same improvement but no change on download)

 

 

 

After installing Opkg traffic control support:

 

still no change on download.

And also I couldt find any settings on opkg package in ui.

Qos doesnt seem to do anything. Without it, router acts the same.

 

Do I miss something?

(all test made with ethernet, no other device connected also)

 

 

Edited February 3, 2021 by some_dsl_problems
ethernet noted

[some_dsl_problems]

For comparison, this is what I get my old wrt1900ac (via ethernet) in between my pc and dsl extra:

Device has LEDE & SQM QoS Enabled

 

 

 

[sergeyk]

4 часа назад, some_dsl_problems сказал:

Do I miss something?

Please try to disable a hardware PPE by a CLI command:

no ppe hardware

on 3.6 beta 2 firmware.

[some_dsl_problems]

 

it made a litte difference

 

[sergeyk]

27 минут назад, some_dsl_problems сказал:

it made a litte difference

 

Please attach a self-test file in a hidden post here right after a failed test.

[Le ecureuil]

5 часов назад, some_dsl_problems сказал:

Do I miss something?

(all test made with ethernet, no other device connected also)

Plz describe you WAN as exact as you can. ADSL? VDSL? Ethernet? Provider's shaping limit?

[some_dsl_problems]

VDSL

 

no other wan connection

Edited February 3, 2021 by some_dsl_problems

[some_dsl_problems]

I have no idea about shaping, or what shaping is. Its a 32mbit vdsl connection as far as I know

[Le ecureuil]

@some_dsl_problems I'll try to look forward for your issues.

[some_dsl_problems]

Just now, Le ecureuil said:

@some_dsl_problems I'll try to look forward for your issues.

I love you

😍

[Le ecureuil]

@some_dsl_problems right now you can start with these commands in cli:

> no interface PPPoE0 ip adjust-ttl

> system configuration save

[some_dsl_problems]

4 minutes ago, Le ecureuil said:

commands in cli:

 

 

seems like getting better

 

http://www.dslreports.com/speedtest/67223515

Edited February 3, 2021 by some_dsl_problems

[Le ecureuil]

@some_dsl_problems plz provide mac of device in LAN with win10 from which you perform tests.

[some_dsl_problems]

3 minutes ago, Le ecureuil said:

provide mac o

[some_dsl_problems]

@Le ecureuil if it helps, I can give you remote acces to my pc, to save your time.

[Le ecureuil]

It is not necessary right now, will try to reproduce on my lab setup. 

[some_dsl_problems]

@Le ecureuil any good news?

[Le ecureuil]

19 часов назад, some_dsl_problems сказал:

@Le ecureuil any good news?

Plz wait, I have many another more important things to be handled before.

[some_dsl_problems]

12 minutes ago, Le ecureuil said:

Plz wait, I have many another more important things to be handled before.

Ok, thank you for the response.

[Muhep Atasoy]

I'm using 100 Mbps internet over fiber. My test result always F. How can I enable SQM for Keenetic Viva. Is my problem related to my isp?

 

[Le ecureuil]

26 минут назад, Muhep Atasoy сказал:

I'm using 100 Mbps internet over fiber. My test result always F. How can I enable SQM for Keenetic Viva. Is my problem related to my isp?

 

Why do your fiber is so asymmetic with only 8 mbps available for upload?

And plz write the name of your ISP interface from Keeentic.

[Muhep Atasoy]

My ISP is TurkNet. But Turk Telekom owns fiber infrastructure and the highest upload speed is 8Mbps for all plans. One year ago it was only 4Mbps.

Edited July 29, 2021 by Muhep Atasoy

[Le ecureuil]

@Muhep Atasoy try following in cli:

> no ppe hardware

> interface ISP tx-queue scheduler cake
> system configuration save

And plz retry bufferbloat tests.